Is food combining important for weight loss?
Posted December 2nd, 2006 at 7:00 AM by Martin Kennedy
Section: Nutrition, Healthy Eating, Health & Fitness, Weight Loss
Books and programs on food combining have been on and off the best-seller lists for years. They should be in the fiction section. The authors claim that eating protein and carbohydrates, or fat and carbohydrates together causes problems because they require different enzymes for digestion, and either acid or alkaline conditions.
They give you elaborate lists of foods that you can or cannot eat at the same meal. If any of this were true, the human race would be extinct. Few foods are “pure” protein, carbohydrate or fat. Your digestive system has evolved to deal with mixed foods, and the enzymes secreted by your pancreas can digest them all in any combination.
Your stomach is strongly acidic, no matter what food you eat. Stomach acid is much stronger than lemon juice, tomatoes or any other acid food. Nothing you eat escapes this acid “soup” while it is in your stomach, so it makes no difference whether you combine acid and alkaline foods.
These authors tell you that the undigested food will ferment and putrify, causing you to accumulate toxins in your intestines. This just doesn’t happen. Your intestines do a very efficient job of breaking down carbohydrates, fats and proteins into their building blocks, which are then absorbed into your bloodstream.
As long as you are not constantly constipated, your colon does an excellent job of removing the waste products of digestion. If you have a problem with constipation, the answer lies not which foods you combine, but in adding fiber and water to your diet.
They even claim that the undigested food makes you fat, which is impossible. To be stored as fat, a food must be broken down into its building blocks and pass from the intestines into the bloodstream. Any undigested food would be excreted, making you thinner, not fatter.
People who lose weight following these nonsensical rules do so simply because they are forced to limit their food choices and therefore consume fewer calories.
Do not confuse these ridiculous diets with serious “combination” recommendations that are made in two special situations:
Diabetics and others who are concerned about sharp rises in blood sugar are advised to eat fruits and root vegetables only in combination with other foods. Fruits and root vegetables contain lots of sugar or quickly digested starches which can cause blood sugar to rise after eating.
However, a healthy diet does not eliminate these foods because they also contain lots of vitamins, minerals and other phytochemicals that your body uses to keep you healthy and prevent diseases. When you eat these foods WITH other foods, particularly proteins or fats, they are digested more slowly. Diabetics should include a variety of fruits and root vegetables in their diet, but eat them with meals, not alone.
Strict Vegetarians who eat no animal products are often advised to COMBINE beans and grains so they will get complete proteins. This is true, but you do not need to eat the foods together at the same meal. The proteins found in meat and dairy products contain all nine essential amino acids (the ones your body needs and cannot make), and so they are called complete proteins.
Most plant sources of protein, such as beans and grains, contain only two to seven of the essential amino acids, so you must eat a variety of these foods to assure that you get them all. However, you can do this over the course of the day or week. Amino acids circulate constantly in your bloodstream and are used as needed. You do not need to eat the foods simultaneously to supply your body with the different amino acids you need.
***Note: We encourage EVERYONE to see a doctor before altering their diet, taking a supplement and/or performing athletic, fitness or other strenuous physical activity. It is your responsibility to evaluate the accuracy, completeness and usefulness of any information, instruction, opinion or advice contained in the content. Please also see our complete disclaimer.***
This post is written by Dr. Gabe Mirkin, M.D. and was originally published on his blog “Fitness and Health E-Zine”.
Dr. Mirkin is board certified in Sports Medicine and has practiced for over 40 years. He has completed more than 40 marathons and was a talk show host of a nationally-syndicated radio program for about 25 years. For more articles by Dr. Mirkin, please check out: www.DrMirkin.com
Please also be advised that Dr. Mirkin’s opinions and the references cited are for information only, and are not intended to diagnose or prescribe. For your specific diagnosis and treatment, consult your doctor or health care provider.
***Note: We encourage EVERYONE to see a doctor before altering their diet, taking a supplement and/or performing athletic, fitness or other strenuous physical activity. It is your responsibility to evaluate the accuracy, completeness and usefulness of any information, instruction, opinion or advice contained in the content. Please also see our complete disclaimer.***
Tags: diabetes, diabetics, diet, diet books, digestion, dr gabe mirkin, food combining, lose weight, strict vegetarians, vegetarian, weight loss
Like what you see? Subscribe to our feed!
The Final Sprint
I agree with this completely, thanks for the post.
June 16th, 2007 at 6:44 amYou are so wrong re. food combining. It not only works it’s healthier than the Standard Am. Diet. You only have to look at our nation to know that what most are doing doesn’t work…duh I’ve been maintaining a 40 lb. weight loss for many years by food combining. You keep touting your S.A.D. way of eating and stay fat, I’ll stick to health and food combining. And by all means, use your empiracle data…
June 29th, 2007 at 1:49 amI like the image of the person in front of the books? Who do I contact to use it in an obesity prevention presentation??
November 16th, 2007 at 2:13 pmI wonder if Dr. Mirkin tried food combining before discounting it.
As someone who has always eaten healthy all my life yet suffered with severe stomach/digestive issues at the same time, I totally disagree with the doctor.
I’m just a few weeks new to “food combining” but it has made a world of difference to my digestive health. All the pain & discomfort I’ve experienced for years has been relieved just by watching how I combine the healthy food I am already used to eating.
February 23rd, 2008 at 11:49 am